Othello and King Lear: A Comparison
A comparative study of two of Shakespeare’s works, Othello and King Lear.
Othello ; King Lear – A comparison If Shakespeare was alive today it is certain that there would be a lot written about him. We would read reviews of his new plays in newspapers, articles about his poetry in the literary papers, and gossip about his love life and his taste in clothes splashed across the glossy magazines. His views about everything under the sun, from the government to kitchen furniture, would probably appear regularly in the colour supplements.
His face would be familiar on television talk shows, his voice well-known from radio broadcasts. There would be so much recorded evidence about his life and his opinions that it would not be hard to write about him. Shakespeare, however, lived some four hundred years ago in the reign of Queen Elizabeth I, when there was no tele- vision or radio, nor even any newspapers as we know them today. Although he was respected as an important person in his own lifetime, nobody ever thought of writing about him until well after his death.
And Shakespeare did apparently not believe in keeping a diary either. So it is largely by luck that the little evidence we have, such as the entry of his birth in the parish register, has survived at all. And yet, by looking carefully at contemporary pictures, by reading contemporary accounts, it is possible to get a good idea of how the boy whose birth is recorded in the Stratford register of 1654 grew up into the man who wrote such famous plays still known all over the world, as we type. Imagery used in Othello and King Lear. In Othello and King Lear Shakespeare uses a lot of imagery. The main image in Othello is that of animals in action, preying upon one another, mischievous, lascivious, cruel or suffering, and through these, the general sense of pain and unpleasantness is much increased and kept constant- ly before us. More than half the animal images used in the play Othello are of Iago, and all those are contemptuous or repellent: a plague of flies, a quarrelsome dog, the recur- rent image of bird-snaring, leading asses by the nose, a spider catching a fly, beating an offenceless dog, wild cats, wolves, goats and monkeys. To these, Othello adds his pictures of foul toads breathing in a cistern, summer flies in the shambles, the ill-boding raven over the infected house, a toad in a dungeon, the monster `to hideous to be shown’, Othello Act III, Sc iii line 107 bird-snaring again, aspics’ tongues, crocodiles’ tears and his reiteration of `goats and monkeys’. Othello act III, Sc iii Act IV, Sc i line 403 In addition, Lodovico very suitably calls Iago `that viper’, Othello Act III, Sc iii line 265 and the green-eyed monster `begot upon itself, born on itself’, Othello Act III, Sc iv line 161, 163 is described or referred to by Iago, Emilia and Desdemona. It is interesting to compare the animal imagery in Othello with that in King Lear. The plays have certain similarities; they were written near together (Othello probably in 1604, King Lear about 1605), they are the most painful of the great tragedies, and they are both studies of torture. But the torture in King Lear is on so vast and on so inhuman a scale, the cruelty of child to parent in the doubly repeated plot is so relentless and ferocious, that the jealous and petty malignity of Iago shrinks beside it. This difference in scale is expressed in the animal imagery. In Othello we see a low type of life, insects and reptiles, swarming and preying on each other, not out of special ferocity, but just in accordance with their natural instincts, mischievous and irresponsible wild cats, goats and monkeys, or the harmless, innocent animal trapped. This reflects and repeats the spectacle of the wanton torture of one human being by another, which we witness in the tragedy, the human spider and his fly; whereas as in King Lear our imagination is filled with the accumulated pictures of active ferocity, of tiger, wolf, wild boar, vulture, serpent and sea-monster, all animals of a certain dignity and grandeur, though seen here only when their desires Are wolfish, bloody, starved and ravenous. Merchant of Venice Act IV Sc i line 137 This represents the terrific scale of the suffering in King Lear, which makes us feel, as we never do in Othello, that the vileness of humanity is so great, so unchecked and universal that if the gods do not intervene, the end of such horrors must come and Humanity must perforce prey on itself, Like monsters of the deep. King Lear Act IV Sc ii line 49 But the gods, who `keep this dreadful pother’, do not intervene, and the most terrible lines in Shakespeare are those breathed by Gloucester in his agony, when he attribu tes to the gods themselves in their dealings with men, not only indifference and callousness, but the sheer wanton delight in torture, which, in Othello, we see exercised only by one human being on another. If animal in action symbolise the main motive in Othello, there is another recurrent image which gives atmosphere and background. As is fitting, with a setting of two seaports, play an important part throughout. Iago, as the soldier of a city which owed its dominance to sea-power, uses sea imagery easily; when complaining that Othello had passed him over for Cassio, he describes himself as `be-lee’d and calm’d; Othello Act I, Sc i line 30 he knows the state has not another of Othello’s `fathom’; Othello Act I, Sc i line 153 he says he must `show out a flag and sign of love’; Othello Act I, Sc i line 157 that Brabantio will take action against Othello to whatever extent the law `will give him cable’; Othello Act I, Sc ii line 17 later, he coarsely describes his general’s marriage in the terms of a pirate taking a prize galleon; he declares to Roderigo he is knit to his deserving `with cables of perdurable toughness’; Othello Act I Sc iii line 343 and when he sees his plots shaping well, he murmurs with satisfaction, My boat sails freely, both with wind and stream. Othello Act III Sc iii line 63 The opening of Act II, when those in Cyprus are anxiously awaiting the arrival of Desdemona and of Othello, is full of sea pictures and personifications, ‘the ruffian wind upon the sea’, the `chidden billow’, and the `wind-shaked surge’, so that it is well in keeping with the setting and atmosphe- re when Cassio, in high rhetorical terms, pictures the seas and rocks as traitors concealed to waylay the ship, who, on catching sight of the beauty of Desdemona, `do omit their mortal natures’, and let her go safely by. Othello’s use of sea images is noteworthy; `they come naturally, for on each occasion they mark a moment of intense emotion. The first, at the height of his happiness, when he rejoins Desdemona, is an exclamation which to us, who know what lies before them, is, in its opening, one of the most poignant and moving in the play: O my soul’s joy! If after every tempest come such calms, May the winds blow till they have waken’d death! Othello Act II, Sc i line 186 The next is at the height of torture, when, having been shown the handkerchief, suspicion become certainty and he vows vengeance. To clinch this, Iago urges patience, and suggests that perhaps his mind may change; to which Othello instantly reacts as his torturer intends, and affirms the unalterable quality of his resolve by comparing it to the `icy current and compulsive course’ Othello act III, Sc iii line 453 of the ebbless Pontic Sea. And at the end, when he has carried out his resolve, and has suffereand realised all, again it is in sea language that he expresses his equally set determination to follow Desdemona: Here is my journey’s end, here is my butt And very sea-mark of my utmost sail. Othello Act V, Sc ii line 267 Literatuur: Shakespeare, His Life, His Language, His Theatre S. Schoenbaum Shakespeare’s Imagery, and what it tells us Caroline Spurgeon Shakespeare and his theatre Phillipa Stewart
The final scene in the play offers the audience closure, and could be seen as the climax to events. The extract begins with death already a clear undertone to proceedings; […]
William Shakespeare wrote King Lear in seventeenth century. It is one of Shakespeare’s most horrific and bloodthirsty tragedies, with most of the main characters dead at the end of the […]
There are many ways in which one would agree with this statement, in that there is an evident contrast between wisdom and foolishness. We see this through The Fool, where […]
According to Aristotle a tragedy should consist of a tragic hero; a character of noble status possessing a fatal flaw. He proposed that the hero’s downfall should be a result […]
The theme of disorder is one of the main and important issues in the play. Lear’s selfish and greedy act of dividing the country, ‘know that we have divided in […]
‘King Lear’ is a tragic play consisting of evil and malevolence in 17th century England. It symbolises what can happen in a kingdom if a bad ruler takes the throne. […]
King Lear is universal – the tragedy is in a distantly remote and deliberately undefined historical period and location. Has resulted in its survival. The emptiness of the stage at […]
Shakespeare is not primarily concerned with motives; he is more interested in the effects of characters’ decisions and natures. In Kind Lear, he focuses on the tragic consequences of two […]
King Lear distinguishes itself as Shakespeare’s bleakest tragedy, for it combines a level of brutality and a moral nihilism that are unparalleled in the rest of his works. The question […]
A comparative study of two of Shakespeare’s works, Othello and King Lear. Othello ; King Lear – A comparison If Shakespeare was alive today it is certain that there would […]