Novels of Manner: Evelina and Pamela, Compared and Contrasted
The birth of the novel occurred in in 1719, with the publication of Robinson Crusoe by Daniel Defoe. This literary form quickly became the most accessible and enjoyable style; therefore, novels began being published rapidly. With nothing for comparison and no pre-issued sets of standards, early novels often had no chapters, spelling errors (the first dictionary was not published until 1755), and no set length or format. As a result, there were many experimental formats going on in the mid-to-late 1700s. One of the most popular form to arise during this period of uncertainty was the epistolary novel.
An epistolary novel is a novel that takes the form of written correspondence between the characters within a story. According to the Encyclopedia Britannica, there are several advantages to this style of novel. First of all, it allows a clear view of what multiple characters are thinking and feeling because the reader is not limited to one point-of-view of focal point. It also allows the reader a more in-depth and broad look at the story itself—the reader is able to see more than one side to every event that occurs (“Epistolary Novels”). Although this particular format of the novel lost popularity in the Nineteenth Century and eventually became rare, it flourished in the Eighteenth Century and served as the preferred platform for a particularly popular genre of early novel: the novel of manners.
A novel of manners is a novel that demonstrates how a person (almost always a woman) should behave in particular social situations and in daily life. According to the Encyclopedia Britannica, the story is “dominated” by the social customs, and the character must learn how she should act and react in certain situations (“Novel of Manners”). This genre was very popular during the Restoration and early in the Romantic period, presumably as a result of the emergence of the rake in literature and society alike. A rake is a man with little regard for morality, especially when it comes to sexuality. The rakeish men of this time often felt that they had the right to a woman’s body, despite her arguments. In many novels of manner, the themes of seduction and rape run rampant. The ultimate goal of the heroine of these tales often is to navigate her way through society politely and with her virtue intact.
The novels Pamela; or, Virtue Rewarded by Samuel Richardson and Evelina; or, the History of a Young Lady’s Entrance into the World by Frances Burney fit neatly into both of these aforementioned categories. Both novels are epistolary novels of manner, thereby they have much in common already. However, they also have differences, in part because one is written by a male and the other female, although both stories have a female protagonist. This paper will attempt to compare and contrast each story, exploring the stylistic and thematic similarities and differences. Ultimately, however, the two novels will be unified in genre and theme, despite having apparent differences.
Pamela; or, Virtue Rewarded was written by Samuel Richardson and published in 1740. It was referred to in “Learning to be Female” as “conduct-of-life” literature (Kerisson 522). The story letters tell the tale of Pamela Andrews, a servant in the household of Lady Booby. After she passes away, her son, Mr. B becomes the head of the household and wastes no time pursuing Pamela. The novel consist of a funny (if infuriating) cat-and-mouse tale of Mr. B’s unrequited love for Pamela, and Pamela cleverly escaping his grasp in order to save her virtue. Mr. B is clearly a rake character, and he attempts to seduce (or rape) Pamela on several occasions. He even hides in her room to watch her undress, and later he goes in disguise as a woman to try to get close to her. On one occasion, Pamela finally believes she is returning to her parents, only to have been tricked by Mr. B and taken to another location, another of his homes. Pamela finally does escape, but then returns out of pity when Mr. B writes to her, telling her that he has fallen ill. Although Pamela is a servant and Mr. B is a member of high society (and despite the fact that he’s literally been trying to rape her for months), the two become engaged, and Pamela handles herself with such grace and refinement that nobody seems to care that she was, at one time, a servant. Mr. B’s sister Lady Davers arrives after Mr. B must leave to attend to sick relatives, and Pamela is repeatedly insulted and ultimately held captive by Lady Davers. Pamela is forced to escape out of a window, where she is helped by Mrs. Jewkes and Monsieur Colbrand. However, being the kind and virtuous person that she is, Pamela ultimately forgive Lady Davers. She also meets Miss Goodwin, a young girl at a boarding school who is thought to be Pamela’s half sister. Eventually, Pamela learns her role as a wife of nobility, and she lives a happy life among the nobility of the land, who enjoy her company. Pamela also makes sure that Miss Goodwin is well-taken care of. Pamela was generally well-received and was what we in the modern day might call a “best seller”. According to Margret Ann Doody, “everybody read it; there was a ‘Pamela’ rage, and Pamela motifs appeared on teacups and fans” (“Introduction to Samuel Richardson’s Pamela”). However, Pamela also had critics that were not so friendly. Some people (of the higher class) were outraged by a rags-to-riches tale and were equally offended by how their people were portrayed in the story. In response to this critique, Richardson made some changes in hopes to pacify the critics.
It was not only the upper-class that took issue with Pamela, but some of Richardson’s contemporaries did as well. Most notably, Henry Fielding wrote the novella An Apology for the Life of Mrs. Shamela Andrews, often simply called Shamela as a direct attack and satire of Richardson’s popular novel. According to “Henry Fielding Shamela Introduction”, the purpose of the parody was to “expose the hypocrisy of contemporary mores” and satirized not only the story itself, but also the political and clerical leaders of the era (LeBlanc). The introduction goes on to explain how, while Pamela uses virtue and is ultimately rewarded, Shamela behaves poorly in order to receive what she wants. Another parody was published by Eliza Haywood in 1741. Her work, entitled The Anti-Pamela; or Feigned Innocence, followed a seemingly innocent young woman named Pamela who used her cunning wit to get whatever she wished from her dim-witted master. However, despite these parodies and earlier criticisms, Pamela enjoyed enormous success.
Evelina; Or, the History of a Young Girl’s Entrance into the World was written by Frances Burney and was published in 1778. Also written in epistolary form, this novel centers around Evelina Annville, a young woman being brought up by Reverend Villars after the death of her mother and her father’s rejection. Evelina is sent to live with Lady Howard and her family in Howard Grove. Evelina then travels to London with the family, where she is introduced into London high society. Evelina’s faux paus serve as a teaching tool for the readers. Evelina attends balls and plays, meets men (some more savory than others) and must learn how to fit in with this unfamiliar society. Evelina meets her grandmother, who concocts a plan to get Evelina’s father to claim her so that she will receive her inheritance. Evelina moves to London with her grandmother and her grandmother’s nephew and his children, who often embarrass Evelina. There, she meets Mr. Macartney, a Scotsman that often seems melancholy. When she sees him about to commit suicide, Evelina heroically saves him. She later finds out that Macartney is her brother. Her father finally claims her, and Evelina receives the money due to her. She also marries Lord Orville, one of the only men with whom Evelina holds a favorable opinion throughout the novel.
Unlike Samuel Richardson, Burney did not face as much criticism for Evelina. Although is was originally published anonymously, she was ousted by one of her contemporaries in a poem that she called “vile”. The dedication of the book itself reads: “The extensive plan of your critical observations, which, not confined to works of utility or ingenuity, ‘is equally open to those of frivolous amusement, -and, yet worse than frivolous, dullness,-encourages me to seek for your protection, since, perhaps for my sins!-it intitles me to your annotations. To re-sent, therefore, this offering, however insignificant, would ill become the universality of your undertaking; though not to despise it may, alas! be out of your power.” In “How to Read Like a Gentlemen” by Gina Campbell, Campbell argues that the introduction is important because Burney realizes that she needs “a benign or at least impartial reception and recognizes that it won’t be granted as a matter of course” (Campbell 557).
Both of these stories, although unalike in plot, have many similarities. Even before delving into the text itself, there are many similarities in Pamela and Evelina. The most apparent comparison is in the format of the text. As was mentioned earlier, both novels are epistolary novels, so each of the tales are told through letters from various characters. Continuing with non-textual similarities, both works were published in the eighteenth century. Pamela and Evelina were well-received (mostly) and widely read. In addition to these surface issues, there are also some apparent thematic similarities. Both of these works can be described as “domestic” fiction, focusing on women in the many trials of courtship, seduction, and love (Ozarska 72). Both tales are coming-of-age and courtship tales that follow a young lady’s adventures into society and eventually marriage. It is also interesting to note that both heroines are unsure who their parents are—Pamela doesn’t know who her mother or father are, and Evelina knows her mother is dead but in unsure who her father is for much of the story. Another family issue present in both of the tales is discovering a sibling. Both Evelina and Pamela meet individuals who later turn out to be their siblings. In addition, both stories have subplots including possible (although not always legitimate) scares of incest.
By the same token, both novels have the same ultimate goal: to teach young women how to behave in society. Although the two novels go about doing this in different ways, the outcome in ultimately the same: you will be rewarded with a comfortable life and a good(?) husband if you act virtuously. In each story, the women are “treading between social classes not sure what their circumstances will amount to” (Anpak). This is to say that neither woman is particularly high-born, although they are (by different circumstances) introduced to high society.
Of course, the novels also have many differences. Stylistically, although they are both primarily epistolary novels, Pamela also contains journal entries, while Evelina does not. This may give Pamela herself more characterization, while we must learn about Evelina from other characters. Another main non-textual difference is that while Evelina was written by a woman, Pamela was written by a man. Although the Introduction does tell us that Richardson “drew profusely on the English popular fiction of his lifetime” in order to characterize Pamela believably, there is some doubt that a man ever could truly capture the thoughts and motivations of a woman and vice versa (Doody). Evelina is also considered to be an early indication of Romanticism, while Pamela is largely considered just a sentimental work.
Despite the fact that maintaining virtue is a huge theme in both novels, the two heroines keep their virtue in different ways. According to “The Appeal of Beauty in Distress as Seen in Fanny Burney’s Evelina and Samuel Richardson’s Pamela: Some Typological and Intertextual Issues”, Pamela’s virtue is “that of passive and negative resistance” while Evelina demonstrates “virtue in action”. This means that while Pamela demonstrates her virtue mainly by fending off unwanted attention and suitors, Evelina actively has to make virtuous decisions while treading this new society. While Pamela is viewed as always doing the right thing, Evelina actually makes mistakes, lies, and even goes after Lord Orville against her guardian’s wishes (Tucker 430). As a result, Evelina is, in many opinions, the more interesting of the two. The novel also adds some humor to an otherwise sentimental novel. By allowing the reader to actually see Evelina make social blunders and other mistakes, they are learning about social blunders and how to avoid them, while reading an amusing tale of a woman fumbling through the unfamiliar territory. It could be argued that while Pamela represents true virtue (always doing the right thing), Evelina represents trial and error– making mistakes, learning from them, and maintaining her dignity, although she does have to apologize occasionally for her social blunders.
Pamela; or, Virtue Rewarded and Evelina; or, the History of a Young Lady’s Entrance into the World are both eighteenth-century novels, written in similar styles and containing similar themes, though there are some differences in the characterizations of Pamela and Evelina, as well as many differences in plot. Although the protagonists of the stories go about navigating high society in different ways, both stories serve as guidebooks for young women entering into high society and beginning to navigate courtship and love.
Despite the differences in themes and plot, the goal is ultimately the same for each novel, and both stories end with the heroines receiving the same reward: marriage to a man outside of her social status. In a time when being a woman could literally be dangerous and often was, it is no wonder that stories of women resisting lustful men, moving up the societal ladder, and learning how to earn oneself a worthy husband were popular. Evelina and Pamela both struggle with difficult men and society, overcome these obstacles with grace, and eventually marry a man, moving them to a higher social status, which undoubtedly was one of the best things a woman could do for herself in this period, and certainly pleased her family as well. These novels, although no longer necessary for women in society, withstand the test of time because of the relatable characters and situations that women continue to identify with, some two hundred years later.
Anpak, Kristy. “Pamela vs Evelina: Dramatic Serenity vs At Lost Country Girl.” BritLit. Baylor University, 2013.
Burney, Frances. Evelina; Or, the History of a Young Woman’s Entrance into the World. Seven Treasures Publications, 2008.
Campbell, Gina. “How to Read Like a Gentlemen: Burney’s Instructions to her Critics in Evelina.” ELH, vol. 57, no. 3, 1990, pp. 557-83.
Doody, Margret Ann. “Introduction to Samuel Jackson’s Pamela.” Viking Press, 1995.
“Epistolary Novel.” Encyclopedia Britannica, 2007.
Greenblatt, Stephen. The Norton Anthology of English Literature, Norton & Co, 2012. “Henry Fielding Shamela – Introduction” Literary Criticism (1400-1800) Ed. Michael L. LaBlanc. Vol. 82. Gale Cengage, 2003.
Kerrison, Catherine. “The Novel as Teacher: Learning to Be Female in the Early American South.” The Journal of Southern History, vol. 69, no. 3, 2003, pp. 513–548.
“Novel of Manners.” Encyclopedia Britannica, 2007.
Richardson, Samuel. Pamela; Or, Virtue Rewarded. Penguin Group, 1985.
Tucker, Irene. “Writing Home: Evelina, the Epistolary Novel and the Paradox of Property.” ELH, vol. 60, no. 2, 1993, pp. 419–439.
Anne Dudley Bradstreet was America’s first published poet. Cotton Mather described her as: “a gentlewoman whose extraction and estate were considerable.” She was an intelligent, well-educated poet, wife, and mother, […]
In Nathanael West’s Miss Lonelyhearts and Thomas Pynchon’s The Crying of Lot 49, the protagonists search for order and meaning. The books are similar in that both suggest the possibility […]
Darwin’s theory of natural selection was influenced by the works of Thomas Malthus, an English political economist. In his “An Essay on the Principle of Population”, Thomas Malthus asserts that […]
Through the consistent allusion to fairy tales throughout both The Necklace and The Son’s Veto, de Maupassant and Hardy are able to present the vulnerability and suffering of the characters […]
As psychologist Rollo May once said: “The opposite of courage in our society is not cowardice, it’s conformity.” Throughout Khaled Hosseini’s novel, The Kite Runner, the reader is exposed to […]
Expressionism is a term which refers specifically to an artist tendency that became popular in the early 20th century. Expressionism itself was not founded by a solo artist; instead it […]
Bernard MacLaverty’s Cal explores the intense conflict between the Roman Catholic nationalist party and the Protestant British police forces of northern Ireland in the late 20th century. MacLaverty tells the […]
‘My genius’, Henry James wrote to William Dean Howells in 1900, ‘I may…say, absolutely thrives [in ‘The Ambassadors’] – it is ‘exquisitely ‘pure’, exquisitely everything’. ‘The Ambassadors’ (1903) was considered […]
Philosophers John Rawls and Hannah Arendt each establish different definitions of freedom that help to judge the legitimacy and purpose of political institutions. And while these definitions are not the […]
The birth of the novel occurred in in 1719, with the publication of Robinson Crusoe by Daniel Defoe. This literary form quickly became the most accessible and enjoyable style; therefore, […]