Legislative Branch Power, Its Limits and Expansion Essay
The constitution of United States is of federalist set up where the states and the federal government share power. The federal government powers are limited and enumerated in the constitution. The “necessary and proper” clause is the last paragraph in article 1, section 8 of the United States constitution. This clause gives implied powers of execution to the federal government. The implied powers are not in the constitution but exist as they are necessary when implementing the articulated powers. The clause provides the federal government with power to make laws that are deemed as necessary and proper. This means that the congress can make laws on anything under the constitution, and this expands the federal powers (Gresham 28).
The clause has two main purposes. First, the clause facilitates government organization through permitting congress to organize the judicial branch. The second purpose is to carry out other enumerated congress powers. The congress can make law on anything outside of the stipulated powers if those laws are necessary and proper (Gresham 28).
John Marshall served as the chief justice of the Supreme Court from 1801-1835. During his tenure, the opinion from the court were used to lay the constitution laws. He is remembered for promoting for the supremacy of the federal laws over the state laws. Marshall’s influential rulings strengthened the supreme courts making them the final reference in the constitution interpretation.
McCulloch v. Maryland in 1819 was the first case in Supreme Court where the necessary and proper clause was applied. The congress in 1790 established a banking corporation to enhance tax collection, promote commerce and support the army. Maryland State executed paying of tax by all the banks operations. James McCulloch a cashier at the bank of United States refused to pay the tax, and the matter went to court.
The case raised the question on whether the congress had the power to charter a bank. Hamilton, the secretary of the treasury was on opinion that congress should exercise the implied powers. Jefferson, the secretary of state, on the other hand, was concerned by the idea a single branch of the government having too much power. Jefferson’s interpretation was on strengthening the states right while Hamilton’s favored a strong federal government (Simon 120).
The court ruled that the state of Maryland was not to undermine the act of congress. The ruling established that the court could use the necessary and proper clause to create banks even though it is not stated in the constitution. McCulloch v. Maryland has raid down the theory of implied powers under the written constitution. John Marshall supported Hamilton and rejected the views of Jefferson, and this endorsed the federal government power. The ruling on the case is believed to be a decisive factor which has contributed to the creation of the federal government in the U.S (Simon 121).
The necessary and proper clause have today been used extensively by the congress. Example is the Gonzales v. Raich (2005). A woman who grew marijuana in California was charged under the federal law for possession of drugs even though medicinal marijuana is legal. The Supreme Court stated that the congress may use the clause on commerce to ban the use of homegrown marijuana. If the homegrown marijuana is traded, it will interfere with the attempt to ban interstate trading of marijuana. This is an exercise of the necessary and proper clause where congress makes laws protect the interstate commerce.
John Marshall works re-shaped the American government and impact are felt even today. His opinion has become the legal basis of successive expansions of federal power. The necessary and proper clause is used by congress to make laws that are not in the constitution, yet necessary in the execution of the stated powers.
Gresham, Gary P. The Legislative Branch of Federal Government: People, Process, and Politics. Santa Barbara, Calif: ABC-CLIO, 2008. Print.
Simon, James F. What Kind of Nation: Thomas Jefferson, John Marshall, and the Epic Struggle to Create a United States. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2003. Print
Introduction The 1920s to late 1950s in the United States saw the emergence of so-called ‘Red Scare’ and McCarthyism. These socio-political phenomena were caused by the birth of Communism and […]
Introduction There are several ways in which multiculturalism constructs, prescribes, and influences the scope freedom in the US. The government institutions and political regimes have been accused of allowing ‘marginalisation’ […]
The Great Depression that started in 1929 is known as the longest economic downturn in the history of the US and other Western countries. Many researchers still cannot come to […]
Introduction Historians have argued over the short-term and long-term impacts of the famous Lewis and Clark Expedition of the early 19th century, especially in economic, social, and political aspects. While […]
Introduction American imperialism and global identity The entry of America into imperialism was orchestrated through the military and economic approach. The aim of this strategy was to exert influence on […]
The Progressive Era refers to the period in American history, which lasted from the late 19th century to the early 20th century. The Progressive Era was an enlightened age, which […]
Introduction Progressivism refers to a reform based movement that reached its peak during the twentieth century. This reform movement emphasized on the reformation of the middle class since numerous changes […]
Introduction Competing visions of freedom and liberty have always been a hallmark of the development of the United States. Throughout the years, many ideas emerged concerning the interpretation of these […]
Introduction The Federalist Party and the Democratic-Republican Party were the two major opposing American political forces that were in confrontation from the late 18th up to the early 19th century. […]
Introduction The constitution of United States is of federalist set up where the states and the federal government share power. The federal government powers are limited and enumerated in the […]