Karl Marx and Max Weber’ Views on Sociological Theory Essay
Comparing Ideas of Marx and Weber
Marx and Weber developed quite different theories concerning the dynamics of social change and the human society’s evolution. Marx believed that the conflict of interests and the fight for resources were the basic driving forces contributing to the society’s evolution and social change (Sanderson 131). Weber believed that the social changes was a result of the interaction of cultural values and the material base (Harper and Leicht 23). Thus, the two thinkers understood that ideas and material basis were instrumental in initiating the social change. However, the theorists had different views on the driving forces of the change as Marx saw it as the conflict between different groups while Weber focused on rationalism or charismatic leadership.
The Role of Conflict and Wealth
For Marx, the distribution of wealth was the major stimulus for the social change. Different social classes were in conflict for resources, which resulted in the social change (Weinstein 122). Weber did not pay as much attention to conflict as Marx did. Weber believed that rationalization was the major force that drove the changes in the society. The conflict could be between the rational (institutions, law) and non-rational (religion), and the societies tend to choose rationality (Michie 1543). According to Durkheim, the major conflict in the society was the crime. The individual’s action is in conflict with the norms that often change (Gunderson 150).
The Glue of the Society
The three theorists saw the aspects that united individuals within the society differently. Marx believed that ideology was the glue that kept the society together (Andersen, Taylor and Logio 335). The theorist also thought that the class ideology was the most important glue that united classes and encouraged them to struggle for wealth and resources. Weber saw rationalization as the most important aspect that held societies together. According to the thinker, the society was based on the strive for an order based on particular traditions and values (Michie 1543). Durkheim stressed that the collective conscience was the glue that united people within societies. The collective consciousness is the set of values, traditions, beliefs accumulated in the course of the society’s development (Gunderson 150).
A Concept to Discuss
As regards Marx’s perspective, the idea of the struggle for resources is the most valuable. This struggle can be seen as one of the most influential driving forces of any changes. Thus, individuals start experiencing their creativity when they want to access some resources. Being more assertive, hardworking, creative and so on can be regarded as the result of people’s struggle for resources (salary, societal status and so on).
Weber’s perspective is interesting in the thinker’s idea on the rationality. Institutions play a significant role in people’s life. Moreover, people manage to create more and more institutions that address some issues. At present, individuals are united, and their efforts create the value in terms of various institutions created. For instance, education is the institution that prepares younger generations to operate. Parents do not have to transfer all their skills to their children as schools, universities and so on do it in a more effective way. Of course, parents may focus on the spiritual or a very specific aspect.
Durkheim’s concept of the collective consciousness is the most relevant. A set of traditions, beliefs and values unites people without setting strict rules or boundaries. People feel connected and empowered when they understand that there is the set of values other people share.
Andersen, Margaret L., Howard F. Taylor and Kim A. Logio. Sociology: The Essentials. Stamford: Cengage Learning, 2014. Print.
Gunderson, Ryan. “Recovering a Disillusioned Modernism: The Enlightened Pessimism of Classical Sociology.” Social Theories of History and Histories of Social Theory. Ed. Harry F. Dahms. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing, 2013. 129-161. Print.
Harper, Charles L., and Kevin T. Leicht. Exploring Social Change: America and the World. New York: Routledge, 2015. Print.
Michie, Jonathan. Readers’ Guide to the Social Sciences. New York: Routledge, 2014. Print.
Sanderson, Stephen K. Rethinking Sociological Theory: Introducing and Explaining a Scientific Theoretical Sociology. New York: Routledge, 2015. Print.
Weinstein, Jay. Social Change. New York: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 2010. Print.
Introduction The notion of power can be looked at as a definite degree control of the individuals and others showing itself through different ways. Whether those individual notice it or […]
An Analysis of Nationalism and Imperialism in Karl Marx’s Communist Manifesto Karl Marx is a political theorist, who is well known for his liberal ideas in Communist Manifesto. He has […]
Introduction Karl Marx was a great German philosopher who lived between 1818 and 1883. Philosophical ideas of Karl Marx revolve around economics, political, and social perspectives of the society. This […]
Introduction Karl Marx is a well known individual in the field of history. Marx was a philosopher, a historian, and a social scientist who engaged himself with a variety of […]
A continuous struggle is going on in the world of Karl Marx, for as long as there is an exploiter and an exploited. Karl Marx lived and struggled all his […]
Introduction Research shows that technology and economic changes are related to each other. However, it is not clear on their causes and effects. Nevertheless, the results of such changes are […]
Most noted for influential ideas in the spheres of economics and labor, development of communist ideology. Marx’s most famous works are “The Communist Manifesto” and “Capital.” Biographical Information Marx’s ideology […]
In this easy, Karl Marx’s theory of alienation will be discussed. The discussion will focus on the meaning of alienation and the structures that promote it in the capitalist society. […]
Life History Karl Marx postulated many economic theories throughout his life culminating in the theory of value. Born to Jewish parents in 1818 in Prussia province, Rhineland, currently called Trier, […]
Comparing Ideas of Marx and Weber Marx and Weber developed quite different theories concerning the dynamics of social change and the human society’s evolution. Marx believed that the conflict of […]