Inspiration and Trust: The Moral Catalysts for True Loyalty in The Scarlet Pimpernel
The ability to inspire is the most important characteristic needed to unify a people with a similar common goal. The relationship formulated between a leader and his followers is based upon the leader’s ability to inspire, thus creating a dynamic that is built upon love, trust, and the willingness to sacrifice. Loyalty in the Scarlet Pimpernel represents an important theme that permeates the whole novel. Chauvelin is the primary antagonist in the book, and represents false loyalty through a one-dimensional relationship with his men. The Scarlet Pimpernel however, builds a follower base and forms relationships built upon the said dynamics: love, trust, and willingness to sacrifice. Through the contrast of Chauvelin and the Scarlet Pimpernel, Orczy conveys that true loyalty and dedication depends on the relationship built by the given leader, rather than a forced dynamic based upon fear or incentivization.
The loyalty between Chauvelin and his men encompasses a forced dynamic of superiority and a fear of retribution rather than a genuine connection based upon inspiration, trust, and love. This dynamic leads to many situations in which this flawed dynamic influences various scenarios that turn out to be unfavorable for Chauvelin. Many situations arise that exemplify the inherent risks of false loyalty in which dedication and trust in something may be one-sided. Commonly, one-sided loyalty and relationships can be attributed to negative characteristics, such as a leader’s un-inspiring presence or fear of retribution in the case of Chauvelin in the Scarlet Pimpernel. Chauvelin possesses underlying characteristics that prove to be unfavorable in contrast to the Scarlet Pimpernel’s inspiring persona. This leads to a rift and disconnect between him and his men, primarily based upon fear rather than inspiration, love, and willingness to sacrifice. “Like true soldiers of the well-drilled Republican army, had with blind obedience, and in fear of their lives, implicitly obeyed Chauvelin’s orders” (Orczy 249). The representation of false loyalty permeates every singular scenario in the book between Chauvelin and his men.
In a sense, fear becomes the underlying reason for Chauvelin’s failure. He does not possess charisma and charm like the Scarlet Pimpernel, he is not considered inspiring by his men, and ultimately only a fear of failure for himself influences his attitude. The singular similarity between Chauvelin and his men is an overarching fear of something, and this proves exactly why Chauvelin suffers such failure at everything he attempts to control, as fear cannot form a sense of true loyalty. His motives lie in preserving ideals that aren’t viewed as inspiring and passionate. Ultimately, his blind arrogance and ego cause him to be self-destructive in every sense. “His men, he knew, were spurred on by the hope of the reward…if the soldiers had a grain of intelligence, if…it was a long ‘if,’ and Chauvelin stood for a moment quite still… and cursed nature, cursed man and woman, and above all, he cursed all long-legged, meddlesome British enigmas with one gigantic curse” (256). Only incentivization can truly motivate and legitimize a certain sense of loyalty for Chauvelin with regard to his men. However, this still reinforces the sense of false-loyalty and bond in the sense that it can only be bought, not created through time, love, the creation of trust, and ultimately willingness to sacrifice.
Sir Percy Blakeney, otherwise known as the Scarlet Pimpernel, builds the league of the Scarlet Pimpernel based upon universal inspiration for doing good, trust in one another, and most importantly the willingness to sacrifice. He possesses the characteristics that are valued in a group of men who strive to achieve the same goal. This in itself is the true reason for the Scarlet Pimpernel’s continued successes throughout the book. The inextinguishable dedication and loyalty displayed by the various members of the League reinforce the ideals of a true positive leader, and his ability to unify. “God knows you have perplexed me, so that I do not know which way my duty lies. Tell me what you wish me to do. There are nineteen of us ready to lay down our lives for the Scarlet Pimpernel if he is in danger” (168). The inexplicable truth is represented through this quotation in which inspiration, trust, and willingness to sacrifice are the primary factors seen through deep-seated loyalty. Loyalty that exceeds any trivial and synthetic relationship exemplified through Chauvelin and his men.
The willingness to sacrifice exhibited by the men of the League of the Scarlet Pimpernel goes to show the true strength of an undying bond between leader and follower. “When first she heard of this band of young English enthusiasts, who, for sheer love of their fellow-men, dragged women and children, old and young men, from a horrible death, her heart had glowed with pride for them” (68). The underlying reason for the young men of the League to participate in such activities can be traced back to the Scarlet Pimpernel himself, as he exemplifies the true characteristics of an inspiring leader. Even to the people of England and abroad, the feelings towards the Scarlet Pimpernel embody the ideal mystical leader. “ Her very soul went out to the gallant and mysterious leader of the reckless little band, who risked his life daily, who gave it freely and without ostentation, for the sake of humanity” (68). Overall, the root of the inspiration for the League of the Scarlet Pimpernel is centered around positive intervention. In this lies the true reason for continued success, as a positive common goal is the cornerstone to building a relationship built upon loyalty.
The contrast between the motives of Chauvelin and Sir Percy in the Scarlet Pimpernel can be represented as easily as comparing black and white. Ultimately, the reason for Chauvelin’s continued failure and Sir Percy’s continued success is viewed through contrasting the built upon relationships and loyalties we see throughout the book. The inherent goodness of saving people from certain death allows for an immediate bond revolving around inspiration and admiration. The ideals that formed the original League of the Scarlet Pimpernel are the true reasons for the continued success, as seen through this essay, loyalty, trust, and the willingness to sacrifice are the primary precursors for success. For Chauvelin, his continued failure is built upon one-sided loyalties, lack of inspiration and true relationships, and motives that supersede any given orders.
In A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, a bildungsroman, James Joyce emphasizes religious and intellectual awakening through the main character Stephen Dedalus. Through his hectic and unsatisfactory […]
Edward Bellamy, in his novel Looking Backward, delineates a futuristic utopia set in the twentieth century in which humanity lives in a much more collaborative and unified manner. No longer […]
The Grammar of the IdolsSalman Rushdie’s “The Prophet’s Hair” reflects on religious practice and worship as a number of people cross paths with a sacred relic that has been stolen […]
As long as history has been recorded, a woman’s role in society was dictated by man, for a long time women accepted this patriarchy. This arrangement can be seen in […]
“Sing in me, Muse, and through me tell the storyof that man skilled in all ways of contending,the wanderer, harried for years on end,after he plundered the strongholdon the proud […]
“A profound and heart-rending study of personality, class and culture” To what extent do you agree with this assessment of the novel?Throughout “The Remains of the Day”, Mr Stevens, the […]
Post-World War II, scientists were considered the heroes of modern society. The nation’s science labs were heavily mobilized and federal spending on research development was over twenty times what it […]
Aravind Adiga’s The White Tiger is a representation of the India that is not often displayed among the media. It is an India that, in its core, incorporates all aspects […]
Notes from Underground written by Fyodor Dostoevsky and Grendel written by John Gardner are both novels which contain characters who suffer immensely as the novel progresses. Notes from Underground is […]
The ability to inspire is the most important characteristic needed to unify a people with a similar common goal. The relationship formulated between a leader and his followers is based […]